Shubman Gill vs Yashasvi Jaiswal – Who Truly Deserves a Spot in Asia Cup 2025 T20 Squad?

The Asia Cup 2025 is just around the corner, and one of the biggest debates in Indian cricket right now is: Who deserves a spot in the T20 format – Shubman Gill or Yashasvi Jaiswal?
Both young openers have impressed fans with their performances, but with only limited spots available, selectors face a tough choice. Shubman Gill’s recent Test heroics and Yashasvi Jaiswal’s IPL brilliance make this a mouth-watering selection battle.

In this article, we break down Gill vs Jaiswal T20I stats, strike rate, consistency, and match-winning abilities to see who should be in India’s starting XI for the Asia Cup 2025.

---

Shubman Gill – Riding High on Confidence After Stunning Test Series

Indian Test captain Shubman Gill has been in phenomenal form. On the recent England tour, Gill smashed a staggering 754 runs in 10 innings during the five-match Test series, averaging 75. He notched up four centuries, including his career-best score of 269 against England in Birmingham. To make things even better, he followed it up with 161 runs in the second innings of the same match.

Shubman Gill vs Yashasvi Jaiswal

This dream run in Tests has led many to believe that Gill could make a strong comeback into India’s T20I squad for the Asia Cup 2025. Reports from RevSports suggest that Gill is not only in contention for selection but might also be handed the vice-captaincy role. Shubman Gill vs Yashasvi Jaiswal

---

Yashasvi Jaiswal – IPL Star and T20 Specialist

On the other hand, Yashasvi Jaiswal has been one of India’s most promising T20 talents since making his debut in August 2023. His aggressive batting style and ability to dominate bowlers in the powerplay make him a strong contender for the Asia Cup squad. Shubman Gill vs Yashasvi Jaiswal

In IPL 2025, Jaiswal delivered multiple match-winning knocks, cementing his place as one of the most dangerous openers in the league. He has already scored a T20I century against Nepal and has shown he can adapt to different conditions. Shubman Gill vs Yashasvi Jaiswal

---

Shubman Gill vs Yashasvi Jaiswal – T20I Career Statistics

Let’s compare their T20 International (T20I) numbers since their respective debuts.

📊 Shubman Gill – T20I Stats

• Matches Played: 21

• Innings: 21

• Total Runs: 578

• Batting Average: 30.00

• Strike Rate: 139

• 50+ Scores: 4 (1 century, 3 half-centuries)

• Best Score: 126* (vs New Zealand, 2023)

• Debut Year: 2023

Gill’s T20I journey began in 2023. His standout innings include:

• 126 off 63 balls* vs New Zealand in 2023

• 77 off 47 balls vs West Indies in 2023

• 66 off 49 balls in July 2024

Against Zimbabwe, Gill scored 170 runs in five innings at an average of 42 and an impressive strike rate of 184 in one of the matches. He also scored 144 runs in three innings against New Zealand with an outstanding average of 72.

---

📊 Yashasvi Jaiswal – T20I Stats

• Matches Played: 20+ (since Aug 2023)

• Total Runs: 723

• Batting Average: 36.00

• Strike Rate: Around 150 (varies by series)

• 50+ Scores: Multiple, including 1 century

• Best Score: 100 (vs Nepal)

• Debut Year: 2023

Some of Jaiswal’s key performances include:

• 138 runs vs Australia at an average of 27

• 141 runs vs Zimbabwe in 2024

• 100 runs in a single innings vs Nepal

---

Strike Rate Comparison – Who Scores Faster?

In T20 cricket, a player’s strike rate is just as important as their batting average.

• Shubman Gill: Overall strike rate of 139 in T20Is. His best came against Zimbabwe with 184 in one match. Against Sri Lanka, he maintained a strike rate of 135, while against West Indies, it dipped to 120.

• Yashasvi Jaiswal: Known for explosive starts, Jaiswal’s strike rate consistently hovers around 150, often giving India a flying start in the powerplay overs. Shubman Gill vs Yashasvi Jaiswal

Verdict: Jaiswal has the edge in strike rate, making him a better fit for the T20 opener role where quick runs are vital.

---

Consistency & Impact in Matches

• Gill’s Strengths: Ability to play long innings, anchor the chase, and convert fifties into hundreds. He’s also proven himself in high-pressure overseas conditions.

• Jaiswal’s Strengths: Fearless approach, quick acceleration, and the ability to take the game away in the first six overs.

• Shubman Gill vs Yashasvi Jaiswal

Gill tends to build his innings steadily, while Jaiswal often goes for aggressive shots right from ball one. Depending on the team’s strategy for the Asia Cup 2025, both styles can be crucial.

---

50+ Scores and Match-Winning Innings

• Gill: 4 scores of 50+, including one T20I century. His 126* vs New Zealand remains one of the finest T20I innings by an Indian opener.

• Jaiswal: Multiple 50+ scores, with his century vs Nepal showcasing his ability to dominate lesser-ranked teams.

• Shubman Gill vs Yashasvi Jaiswal

When it comes to big-match temperament, Gill has shown his capability in Tests and T20Is alike, whereas Jaiswal’s IPL track record suggests he thrives under pressure too.

---

Asia Cup 2025 Selection Dilemma – Who Fits Better?

The big question for selectors is: Do they prefer Gill’s consistency and leadership potential or Jaiswal’s attacking powerplay dominance?

If India wants:

• A stable opener who can anchor the innings: Pick Shubman Gill.

• Shubman Gill vs Yashasvi Jaiswal

• A power-hitter who can maximize the first six overs: Pick Yashasvi Jaiswal.

It’s also possible both could be included, with one opening and the other at No. 3.

---

Expert Opinions

Several former cricketers believe Gill’s overall form and leadership skills make him the safer choice for the vice-captain role. Others argue that in T20 cricket, strike rate is king – making Jaiswal the better option for the Asia Cup.

One thing is certain: India is blessed with an abundance of young batting talent, and whoever gets selected will be crucial for India’s Asia Cup 2025 campaign.

---

Final Verdict – Gill or Jaiswal?

Statistically, Jaiswal has the better average and strike rate in T20Is, which suits the fast-paced demands of the format. However, Gill’s proven ability to play match-winning innings against top-tier teams can’t be ignored.

Perhaps the best solution for the Asia Cup 2025 is to have both in the squad and decide the playing XI based on conditions and opposition.